Saturday, November 21, 2026

Checkerspot comparison

Sharing some images I put together as part of a recent discussion on checkerspots.
In the image below, left to right:
Euphydryas chalcedona females from Siskiyou County May 4, 2008, and a male/female pair from LA County (1940s specimens).
Euphydryas colon colon from the Clark/Skamania county line in WA, most from July 14, 2009.
Euphydryas colon "Central WA Cascades segregate" from northern Kittitas County, almost all collected from Reecer Creek on June 27-29, 2009.
Euphydryas anicia veazieae from northern Kittitas County (just east of Reecer but also in an area that hosts colon later), mostly June 1, 2022.



What I've observed over the years (subjective to my corner of the world):
The "cream/white-dotted abdomen" identifier often mentioned in descriptions of chalcedona vs. other checkerspots predominantly applies to the females.
In SW Oregon and northern CA, E. chalcedona pretty consistently has cream/white-dotted abdomens, with 6 segments clearly dotted and usually a smudgy 7th, and occasionally a third spot between the pairs on each segment.
Elsewhere in OR and WA, clearly dotted abdomens is the exception rather than the rule for E. colon and E. anicia. At best, they have 5-6 segments with smudgy spots, usually only 2-3, and *almost* never with third spots down the middle.


I cannot speak to other parts of their range, although this seems to hold true in photos I've seen.
I like to describe chalcedona in southern Oregon as having more of a "brassy" appearance, it's a weird yellowish/brass tint that isn't picked up very well in most photos and becomes less obvious as specimens age, compared to colon being a super rich velvety black that I liken to Parnassius larvae. I will also add that the black of veazieae is more of a smoky dark gray. The first image above makes them look more black than they really are, the second image (closeup of abdomens) shows the difference a bit better.

E. colon in western WA and OR predominantly use snowberry. In Kittitas County, they primarily use snowberry in the SW (ssp. wallacensis in the Manastash-Umtanum area), while the "Central WA Cascades seg." on the northern side (Reecer-Naneum-Colockum areas) of the Kittitas Valley are almost entirely on Penstemon fruticosus (here is a female I photographed on July 12 ovipositing on  fruticosus). That northern series of hills is where the E. colon "Central WA Cascades segregate" and E. anicia veazieae occur in sympatry. Genitalic dissection over many years has consistently shown the differences between the two. The colon segregate there flies from late May to mid-July, peaking in late June. Of 54 specimens I have of the segregate from Kittitas County, my dates range from 5/30 to 7/15, plus one on 8/2 from a higher elevation.

E. anicia veazieae in that location mostly flies in early to mid-May. The specimens in the image above were collected on June 1 and are showing a fair bit of wear; there were tons of females and very few males that day, I had to work to get that many males. They primarily use Penstemon gairdneri and P. speciosus, with some records (mostly post-diapause) on Castilleja thompsonii.
In early June, it is quite obvious to have well-worn veazieae flying with mint-fresh colon in these hills.